Don't Do It Yourself
How to Choose Email Marketing Agency

How to Find & Choose an Email Marketing Agency in 2024

Effective email marketing is not just about sending emails; it's about engaging your audience, nurturing leads, and driving conversions. The right email marketing agency will help you create tailored strategies that yield measurable results.

Learn the essential factors to consider, from understanding your own objectives to evaluating an agency's expertise, so you can make an informed choice.

Advertising Disclosure

What Does an Email Marketing Marketing Agency Do?

What Does an Email Marketing Agency Do

An email marketing agency creates, manages, and optimizes email marketing campaigns for businesses. Here are some key functions that an email marketing agency typically performs:

  • Email strategy development, including defining the KPIs and relevant audience segments.
  • Email content creation, including copywriting, design, and personalization.
  • List building, maintenance, and segmentation
  • Email execution and automation, including scheduling and A/B testing
  • Analytics and reporting on open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and revenue generated
  • Legal compliance and proper email deliverability

Benefits of Working with an Email Marketing Marketing Agency

Benefits of Working with Email Marketing Agency

Working with an email marketing agency can improve the effectiveness of your email campaigns and your overall marketing strategy. Here are five key benefits of hiring an email marketing agency:

Deep Knowledge of Best Practices

Email marketing experts stay up-to-date with industry best practices, legal requirements, and effective strategies. They can help you navigate the complexities of email marketing, from design to delivery. They ensure that your campaigns resonate with your audience and comply with regulations such as CAN-SPAM or GDPR.

Efficiency and Automation

A knowledgeable email marketing agency sets up automated workflows, such as welcome series, re-engagement campaigns, or cart abandonment emails. These operate around the clock, dramatically improving customer engagement and conversion rates without ongoing manual effort.


Email marketing agencies know how to segment your audience for targeted messaging. By personalizing emails based on consumer behavior, demographics, or past interactions, they can significantly improve engagement and conversion rates.

Data-Driven Decision Making

An email marketing agency will track important metrics like open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and ROI. They can interpret this data to provide insights and recommendations. This enables you to make informed, data-driven decisions that improve future campaigns.

Qualities to Look for in an Email Marketing Marketing Agency

Qualities to Look for in Email Marketing Agency

When considering hiring an email marketing agency, it's essential to look for a range of qualities to ensure a successful partnership. Here are eight important traits to consider:

Expertise with Relevant Campaigns

Look for an agency with a proven track record in email marketing, preferably within your industry. An experienced agency will have the skills to craft effective strategies and know how to troubleshoot common issues.


A good agency should have a creative team that can come up with innovative designs, compelling copy, and unique campaigns that resonate with your target audience.

Technical Proficiency

The agency should be well-versed in the technical aspects of email marketing, including list management, segmentation, and high deliverability rates. Knowledge of different email marketing platforms is also beneficial.

Data-Driven Approach

An effective email marketing agency will focus on metrics and analytics to drive decisions. They should offer regular reporting and insights into key performance indicators like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates.

Compliance and Ethical Practices

The agency should have a deep understanding of legal regulations like CAN-SPAM or GDPR, to ensure that your campaigns are compliant. They must follow ethical practices when handling user data and list management.

Customer-Centric Approach

Choose an agency that puts the customer at the center of all strategies. This focus ensures that the email campaigns will provide value to the audience, which in turn can drive higher engagement and conversions.

How to Find a Reputable Email Marketing Agency

How to Find Reputable Email Marketing Agency

Finding a reputable email marketing agency involves a multi-step process to ensure that you select a firm well-suited to your needs and goals. Here are six essential steps:

Define Your Goals and Budget

Before you start contacting agencies, define what you want to achieve with your email marketing campaigns. Whether it's improving customer engagement, increasing sales, or something else, having clear objectives will help you communicate your needs more effectively. Additionally, set a budget to help you narrow down your options.

Research Agencies

After you’re clear on what you want from an email marketing agency, start your search. Check for agencies online and ask for recommendations. One of the best ways to find email marketing agency partners is to work with Agency Matchmaker to get a personalized shortlist of the best options.

We also created an entire guide on the top email marketing agencies to consider. Learn more about where to find the best email marketing agencies online in our guide.

Request Proposals and Quotes

Once you have a shortlist of agencies that fit your criteria, reach out to them to request proposals. A detailed proposal will give you an idea of the agency's strategy, timeline, and cost. Compare these against your own goals and budget to see if there's a match.

Conduct Interviews

Arrange interviews with the agencies that seem most aligned with your needs. During these discussions, ask questions about their experience, team composition, and communication style. Also, inquire about their client retention rate, which can be an indicator of customer satisfaction.

Review Contracts Carefully

Before making a decision, thoroughly review the terms of engagement, including the scope of work, payment terms, and any other obligations. Make sure you understand what is and isn't included in the service package. Seek legal advice if you're unclear about any terms.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an email marketing agency, and what do they do?

An email marketing agency specializes in creating, managing, and optimizing email campaigns for businesses. They handle email strategy, content creation, list management, campaign execution, and analytics. Their goal is to boost customer engagement and drive conversions.

Why should I hire an email marketing agency?

Hiring an agency brings expertise and efficiency to your email marketing efforts. They can craft targeted, data-driven campaigns, freeing you to focus on core business activities. They can also help improve key metrics like engagement and conversion rates through optimization.

If you'd like to start with a freelancer rather than an agency, we've created a list of skills email marketers need to have. Hopefully, this helps you hire an email marketing specialist that suits your needs.

How much does an email marketing agency cost?

The cost of hiring an email marketing agency varies widely based on the -services provided, the complexity of your campaigns, and the agency's experience. Prices can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars per month. Always request a detailed quote for budget planning.